{ "schema_version": "operator-workflow/v1", "request": "Independently review the complete retained visible text from the GLM DCP1 65536-completion-token diagnostic for coherence, degeneration, completeness, and useful-output comparison with the incumbent; do not execute generated code or infer uncaptured reasoning behavior.", "gate_state": "not_required", "targets": { "implementing_model": "GPT-6 Astra", "evaluated_model": "GLM-5.3-Flash DCP1", "reviewer_model": "GPT-5.6 Sol", "source_revision": "731309e499ade9ad0043afbe9024a108cc1285f2", "candidate_native_sha256": "e285b5e221099bccb1db46e04315749072c3da88e008e637dd343156c1bc843a", "candidate_visible_sha256": "4053e63d747bae643735a315b4bad7716971e5b5f59a0f4e91c43381f7c02723", "incumbent_native_sha256": "c7fcf161b54145301617d63a486ed5c7aadbd1ce2bd637f5f69efb4e922d0690" }, "tools_used": [ { "name": "complete_visible_text_review", "source_class": "manual", "ok": true, "dry_run": true, "confirmed": true, "target": "all 468 retained visible lines; no generated-code execution", "error": null }, { "name": "offline_repetition_and_structure_probe", "source_class": "manual", "ok": true, "dry_run": true, "confirmed": true, "target": "candidate visible text and incumbent retained artifact", "error": null }, { "name": "workflow_packet_validate", "source_class": "manual", "ok": true, "dry_run": true, "confirmed": true, "target": "this operator-workflow/v1 packet", "error": null } ], "artifacts": [ { "kind": "finding_summary", "path": "long-output-64k.json", "severity": "high", "classification": "confirmed", "summary": "The native suite result remains a completion-budget failure: finish_reason=length at 65536 reported completion tokens, with three complete chapters, a fourth parser chapter cut off mid-statement, and no terminal marker. It must not be relabeled as a completed guide or suite pass.", "references": [ "long-output-64k-summary.json", "long-output-64k-visible.txt:1", "long-output-64k-visible.txt:330", "long-output-64k-visible.txt:468" ] }, { "kind": "finding_summary", "path": "long-output-64k-visible.txt", "severity": "none", "classification": "refuted", "summary": "No visible degeneration or off-topic drift was found. The answer remains a coherent task-runner handbook from requirements through workspace, lexer, and parser; chapters are distinct and later prose/code follows earlier vocabulary. Offline full-text probes found zero duplicate normalized sentences of at least eight words, zero duplicate paragraphs of at least twenty words, zero duplicate thirty-word windows, and a maximum identical-token run of two.", "references": [ "long-output-64k-visible.txt:1", "long-output-64k-visible.txt:118", "long-output-64k-visible.txt:197", "long-output-64k-visible.txt:330", "long-output-64k-visible.txt:468" ] }, { "kind": "finding_summary", "path": "long-output-64k-summary.json", "severity": "medium", "classification": "confirmed", "summary": "Useful visible output regressed materially against the matched incumbent diagnostic. DCP1 retained 24123 visible characters, 5921 exact visible tokens, and three complete chapters plus part of chapter four; the incumbent retained 70772 visible characters and eleven complete chapters plus part of chapter twelve. Both report the same 65536 completion-token ceiling, finish_reason=length, prompt_tokens=279, and the same assignment. This is a descriptive one-attempt regression, not a throughput or reliability estimate.", "references": [ "long-output-64k-summary.json", "baseline-long-output-64k.json", "baseline-long-output-64k-independent-review.json" ] }, { "kind": "finding_summary", "path": "long-output-64k-summary.json", "severity": "medium", "classification": "confirmed_limit", "summary": "The evidence cannot explain the visible-output regression. DCP1 retains 252061 reasoning characters as metadata, but reasoning_tokens is null and full reasoning was intentionally not retained. No claim of a reasoning loop, productive deliberation, or runtime allocation defect is supported. The incumbent visible token count is also unavailable, so the exact comparison is characters and chapter coverage rather than candidate-versus-incumbent token counts.", "references": [ "long-output-64k-summary.json", "baseline-long-output-64k-independent-review.json" ] }, { "kind": "finding_summary", "path": "long-output-64k-visible.txt", "severity": "low", "classification": "confirmed_out_of_scope", "summary": "Coherence does not establish integrated code correctness. Visible static seams include workspace.py referencing ConfigError without importing it, lexer punctuation omitting the dot required by the documented env.CI syntax, and a mutable TaskSpec conflicting with the chapter's frozen-configuration invariant. Generated code was not executed, and these defects do not change the long-generation coherence result.", "references": [ "long-output-64k-visible.txt:9", "long-output-64k-visible.txt:95", "long-output-64k-visible.txt:133", "long-output-64k-visible.txt:176", "long-output-64k-visible.txt:201", "long-output-64k-visible.txt:237" ] }, { "kind": "disposition", "path": "campaign-plan.md", "severity": "none", "classification": "confirmed", "summary": "Continuing to the frozen routed-admission gate is consistent with the predeclared campaign and is not a waiver. campaign-plan.md permits the separate 65536-cap diagnostic to end with stop or length when visible content is coherent and usage is retained. Those diagnostic conditions are met, while the native completion failure and useful-output regression remain recorded. The independent natural-output gate separately passed with 18016 visible tokens, stop finish, all 24 chapters, and its terminal marker.", "references": [ "campaign-plan.md:13", "natural-long-output-1-independent-review.json", "long-output-64k-summary.json" ] }, { "kind": "breakage_probes", "path": "long-output-64k-visible.txt", "items": [ { "axis": "fail_closed_unreadable_state", "input_state": "Visible text, usage, finish reason, identity, or native failure unavailable", "wrong_result": "Infer coherence or completion from partial evidence", "result": "refuted; full visible text, usage, finish, equal before/after identity hashes, and failure are retained" }, { "axis": "malformed_boundary_input", "input_state": "Guide reaches the 65536 completion boundary mid-code", "wrong_result": "Treat syntactically incomplete output as completed", "result": "confirmed boundary failure and retained as native failed" }, { "axis": "resource_exhaustion_or_missing_bounds", "input_state": "Generation consumes the full configured completion budget", "wrong_result": "Unbounded generation or silent success", "result": "refuted; request stops at the declared ceiling with finish_reason=length" }, { "axis": "state_drift_across_runtime_and_evidence", "input_state": "Managed identity changes during the attempt or owner/kernel failure is omitted", "wrong_result": "Attribute output to the qualified recipe after drift", "result": "refuted by equal before/after identity artifacts and retained zero-match kernel evidence; this does not prove general reliability" } ] }, { "path": "long-output-64k.json", "sha256": "e285b5e221099bccb1db46e04315749072c3da88e008e637dd343156c1bc843a" }, { "path": "long-output-64k-visible.txt", "sha256": "4053e63d747bae643735a315b4bad7716971e5b5f59a0f4e91c43381f7c02723" }, { "path": "long-output-64k-summary.json", "sha256": "1b375d1979c6af900bf16102dc0546881c816b248f31e44d8c4ab609f57955bd" }, { "path": "baseline-long-output-64k.json", "sha256": "c7fcf161b54145301617d63a486ed5c7aadbd1ce2bd637f5f69efb4e922d0690" }, { "path": "baseline-long-output-64k-independent-review.json", "sha256": "309e3e3d297d009e0746e6dc0149b6e22aaa99ee27ca51b5d3fe10ac9166c114" } ], "advisory_priors": [ { "summary": "The evaluated GLM model did not grade itself; GPT-5.6 Sol independently reviewed the complete retained visible output and Astra-authored evidence framing.", "advisory_only": true, "promotion_quality_evidence": false }, { "summary": "No generated code, model request, router operation, lifecycle action, service change, or GPU action was performed.", "advisory_only": true, "promotion_quality_evidence": false }, { "summary": "This single diagnostic supports visible coherence through truncation; it does not establish completion, correctness, reliability, or causal attribution for output allocation.", "advisory_only": true, "promotion_quality_evidence": false } ], "recommendation": "needs_more_data", "human_gate_required": false, "promoted": false }