{
  "schema_version": "operator-workflow/v1",
  "request": "Independently review the final parent/candidate scenario-comparability skill addition after an accidental output-cap mismatch",
  "gate_state": "not_required",
  "targets": {
    "repository": "/workspace/anvil-serving",
    "file": "skills/anvil-serving-llm-qualification/references/runtime-investigation.md",
    "baseline_before_addition_sha256": "039acfed3458d820d3eec7c0fe1cfa00c8ae568408b7645f2aa8cc65a9284a00",
    "rejected_intermediate_sha256": "f535c7540e631d9da97067168c16e82c4509622b771b4de9596e30ec7201fe22",
    "final_candidate_sha256": "3944a809baeed048df70549dc8fef55edaa0087b4271922bf76c9681dface277",
    "implementing_model": "gpt-6-astra",
    "reviewer_model": "gpt-5.6-sol",
    "scope": "final three-line instruction addition only; no live action or broad replay"
  },
  "tools_used": [
    {
      "name": "git_status_and_read_only_file_inspection",
      "source_class": "cli",
      "ok": true,
      "dry_run": true,
      "confirmed": false,
      "target": "/workspace/anvil-serving",
      "error": null
    }
  ],
  "artifacts": [
    {
      "path": "/tmp/anvil-runtime-skill-review-20260923/final-scenario-comparability-delta-operator-workflow-v1.json",
      "kind": "findings-summary",
      "evidence_scope": "instruction-delta-review",
      "promotion_quality_evidence": false,
      "summary": {
        "disposition": "accept",
        "high": 0,
        "medium": 0,
        "low": 0,
        "intermediate_rejected": 1,
        "promoted": false
      }
    }
  ],
  "advisory_priors": [],
  "recommendation": "needs_more_data",
  "review_disposition": "accept_final_delta",
  "human_gate_required": false,
  "promoted": false,
  "delta_review": {
    "findings": [],
    "acceptance": "ACCEPT",
    "reference": "skills/anvil-serving-llm-qualification/references/runtime-investigation.md:18",
    "behavior": "Mechanically compare normalized parent and candidate scenario fields before traffic, retain the diff including both output caps and reasoning policy, preserve accidental mismatches as failed or non-comparable attempts, and correct them under a new scenario identity.",
    "fresh_mismatched_budget_control": {
      "input_state": {
        "parent_anchor_output_cap": 2048,
        "candidate_anchor_output_cap": 512,
        "other_intended_delta": "DCP1 only",
        "reasoning_policy": "otherwise matched"
      },
      "wrong_result": "Treat the 512-cap no-answer as a matched DCP1 regression, erase it after a 2048 retry, or combine it with the matched 2048 results.",
      "required_result": "The normalized pre-traffic diff catches the cap mismatch. If the accidental attempt already exists, retain it as failed and non-comparable. Create a new scenario identity with the 2048 cap; only that matched identity may support the later pass and 3/3 overlap statement.",
      "classification": "pass"
    },
    "reasoning_policy_transfer": {
      "input_state": "Output caps match, but the candidate silently changes reasoning policy.",
      "required_result": "The same normalized diff blocks traffic or marks any existing attempt non-comparable; the corrected policy receives a new scenario identity.",
      "classification": "pass"
    },
    "incident_control": "The accidental 512-cap no-answer remains evidence of that malformed comparison only. It cannot close or worsen the incident; the exact 2048 matched retry and three repeated overlap passes remain bounded mitigation evidence, not root-cause proof.",
    "mutation_control": "The addition authorizes no model request, reload, repair, route change, or promotion. Existing preview, confirmation, resource-owner, and human gates remain intact.",
    "publication_control": "Publication must retain the 512-cap attempt as failed/non-comparable and identify the corrected 2048 scenario separately. It may report the three matched passes but cannot rewrite the first attempt or imply root-cause resolution or promotion.",
    "intermediate_finding": {
      "classification": "confirmed and resolved",
      "severity": "medium",
      "detail": "The intermediate text required only an unspecified comparison, which could be satisfied by the same fallible visual review that allowed the live mismatch. The final text now requires a mechanical normalized diff and retention of that diff."
    },
    "residual_risk": [
      "The normalized comparison must include the complete scenario schema; the explicit output-cap and reasoning-policy fields are minimums, not an allowlist.",
      "Matched 3/3 exposure remains bounded mitigation evidence and does not estimate crash rate or establish kernel root cause."
    ],
    "missing_tests": [],
    "promotion_decision": "No promotion was requested or authorized; promoted=false remains mandatory."
  }
}