{
  "schema": "anvil-serving.promotion-evidence-summary/v1",
  "date": "2026-10-17",
  "decision": {
    "label": "current",
    "human_approved": true,
    "live_primary": true,
    "fleet_convergence": false,
    "public_web_publication": true,
    "operator_assessment": "best current fit for this deployment, explicitly selected by the operator on 2026-10-17",
    "comparison_scope": "pinned NVIDIA FP4 r2 versus retained EXL3 r11; operational selection, not an exhaustive model-quality ranking"
  },
  "identity": {
    "model": "nvidia/GLM-5.3-Flash-FP4-Local",
    "revision": "76348ddb2be2e35e39ecfc00e75dc07703f4f3d5",
    "served_name": "glm53-nvidia-fp4-local-tp2-327k-c4-mtp3-r2"
  },
  "acceptance": {
    "direct_protocol_checks": 9,
    "routed_preflight": "8/8",
    "eight_image_corpus": "18/18",
    "coding_tool_continuation": "1/1 across five requests",
    "fresh_capacity": "client C1/C2/C4; 12 scored requests; no observed OOM, preemption, or refusal; client C4 sampled maxima: engine active 2, queued 3, occupancy 4 (independent time maxima, not summed; not four simultaneous decodes)",
    "primary_node_pi_tool_smoke": "passed; one fresh nonce/tool call; no session",
    "companion_node_openclaw_gateway": "passed; one successful exec tool; exact nonce; primary alias; 327680 context; normal stop; no fallback",
    "mac_openclaw_gateway": "passed after one retained headless exec policy failure; retry used one permitted read tool; exact nonce; primary alias; 327680 context; normal stop; no fallback",
    "gateway_metric_limits": "native usage counters unavailable; no engine TTFT/decode exposed; wall-clock duration is not engine latency; existing 17-family capacity evidence remains authoritative",
    "additional_pi": "five tested process combinations passed; one successful read each; exact nonce/provider/primary alias; stop and agent_settled; post-run executable hashes, not immutable at-launch PATH custody",
    "additional_pi_accounting": "seven client turns: two lost captures excluded, two controlled replacements accepted, three additional combinations accepted; upstream HTTP count not inferred; Mac stale model-pattern warning retained",
    "primary_hermes_profiles": "two fresh CLI turns passed; one terminal read each; exact nonce/normal stop; exact-session export binds approved router; configured provider anvil, runtime provider custom; native reported api_calls=2 each",
    "native_cli_metric_limits": "native usage and client wall time retained; TTFT/prefill/decode/KV/engine concurrency unavailable in these functional captures; Hermes context/fallback/effective reasoning unavailable; existing 17-family performance evidence remains authoritative"
  },
  "fleet": {
    "native_workflows": "original failed job cancelled and freshly quiescent through supported owner recovery; original history retained; no redispatch; corrected successor profiles staged on three hosts; complete workflow acceptance pending",
    "mini_and_mac_client_smokes": "bounded Gateway smokes passed; earlier evaluator credential failures were before dispatch; first Mac Gateway exec policy failure retained",
    "remaining_client_acceptance": "Pi Web, existing conversations, running Hermes Gateway and full native propagation remain unaccepted; operator confirmed the secondary host runtime is intentionally disabled; preserve that state and its acceptance gate until it is available again",
    "native_custody": "terminal workflow and native quiescence independently verified; exact custody, child result and cancellation receipt retained; supersedes the earlier missing-custody audit",
    "open_webui_catalog": "passed; six approved aliases; three active accounts; managed preview/apply/scheduled/repeat passed; repeat changed=0; credentials unchanged; no model/router/WebUI restart"
  },
  "publication_readback": {
    "status": "complete_with_native_discovery_limitation",
    "grafana_comparison": "passed; 11 panels",
    "prometheus_and_observer": "792 numeric campaign observations, 17 metric families, 396 per arm",
    "workbench": "92 configured cards; 24 exact campaign cards, 12 per arm; pinned revision and engine fields match",
    "apply_and_repeat": "canary and primary passed",
    "native_discovery": "historical model label retained pending native fleet reconciliation; comparison metrics and evidence cards independently verified",
    "public_pages_deployment": true,
    "observation_scope": "original dashboard receipt plus dated served-primary-finding HTTP readback; new recovery source publication tracked separately",
    "public_pages_readback": {
      "observed_at": "2026-10-17T23:58:54.558155+00:00",
      "url": "https://fakoli.github.io/anvil-serving/findings/2026-10-17-glm53-nvidia-fp4-promotion/",
      "status": 200,
      "sha256": "399eaca093f1cc79411207d379212d0592cc7b27e6ed2e3d90de1f75feca8f0b",
      "checks": {
        "76348ddb2be2e35e39ecfc00e75dc07703f4f3d5": true,
        "glm53-nvidia-fp4-local-tp2-327k-c4-mtp3-r2": true,
        "14.25": true,
        "strict controlled-output workload failed": true
      },
      "scope": "served primary finding before the latest recovery followup; no claim that pending source is published"
    }
  },
  "source_summaries": [
    {
      "role": "direct acceptance",
      "sha256": "a308de1470fefb7b8a9db72c4842412fe178142bee1b5d9393ec48cbc3d6094d"
    },
    {
      "role": "routed acceptance",
      "sha256": "0f85d7acf275e82f22d0db7e459ebb4f2fd15b3476c79c3ad6a54d4fe0d79818"
    },
    {
      "role": "routed acceptance hash addendum",
      "sha256": "ae7f99fb315c1b5003b64b419ad3e91c19bdc236ea32198326e0c04e5cad2fd0"
    },
    {
      "role": "fresh capacity acceptance",
      "sha256": "b81b64ab48458cbce2e638a85cc12cbd1cd525b7caf3d453ef6c77579e4ddd49"
    },
    {
      "role": "Primary Node Pi tool smoke",
      "sha256": "9e2a874a10fee91bda3570912e69df843913686d33292a5b55717f328b8211b2"
    },
    {
      "role": "fleet client minimal attempts",
      "sha256": "f246995190c6b1aae793564974fb7dd8267184bf9a2ac241daeb6f38228e777a"
    },
    {
      "role": "publication live readback",
      "sha256": "79157a1c8216ec752c4ca447479b0c41f8bcdaae941a6759df906d912b95748c"
    },
    {
      "role": "bounded Gateway acceptance",
      "sha256": "74811f9c9f9ad5134bb6aab128f7e14c9781f1a42d53d6ccd60b12d2dcf09153"
    },
    {
      "role": "independent Gateway export verification",
      "sha256": "75b663c537630e149d27c652c01f42b34ffbf71075e6ddd625cfea14c181475c"
    },
    {
      "role": "native workflow custody audit",
      "sha256": "6395ecdd36b22b6db05f550815cc633a8345925792a6b8218ded72888e24649c"
    },
    {
      "role": "WebUI catalog live acceptance",
      "sha256": "e39f3269225d3ebc1ea2c058a4eb954ebec0ad141886ae975cc20dffd7b81e3c"
    },
    {
      "role": "additional Pi functional acceptance",
      "sha256": "0057a5e81bb54504590fee2d2f3e12db6caa9820c1d8a84018e443f8e0d50ce2"
    },
    {
      "role": "primary Hermes profile functional acceptance",
      "sha256": "6a8d2e5ab48d5ff108efdf29c0fbc4b78857df64f8a216eeec605f51fbdbbf7f"
    },
    {
      "role": "initial promotion summary; historical fleet state",
      "path": "initial-promotion-summary.json",
      "sha256": "0d8ae7b60648bb2496c694d8a92ecc95b3c0a1dccfa96c61d1acd48584aa90ab"
    },
    {
      "role": "original workflow supported settlement",
      "sha256": "c4a6e2273039a96b0dba1705dd411aad710f91bf3e7040d51763f19a07f5c916"
    },
    {
      "role": "repaired native runtime repeat",
      "sha256": "6bcef2137547e80f8f3fa72a94dbc427a0c7ba307438e7589a9254d6b5778c59"
    },
    {
      "role": "corrected native profile stage",
      "sha256": "9bb3a547b26a2c26cef23fa31b58b07fe2e6b10cea33684eb7221e79f80e13cd"
    },
    {
      "role": "independent source identity review",
      "sha256": "ec3d24759adf5456c5c2f322ed453d344b80cd10f1f83dc5b8bafb7b99819a2f"
    },
    {
      "role": "served primary finding HTTP readback",
      "sha256": "733bc8607d449a1f355348db4712c92154e664ae1b18759322934a2fb403de30"
    }
  ],
  "kv_accounting": {
    "path": "kv-accounting.json",
    "sha256": "fd333754afa453bdaee9961c9928914c8249b2129a5b5381f8431b7a6798cdb8",
    "pool_total_gib": 14.25,
    "status": "configured pool; measured block fractions; estimated occupied/unused GiB",
    "fresh_c4_estimated_occupied_gib": 2.3172897196261677,
    "fresh_c4_estimated_unused_pool_gib": 11.932710280373833
  },
  "updated_at": "2026-10-18T00:09:00Z",
  "durability": {
    "native_runtime": "separately pinned repaired client wheel installed on three hosts; repeat changed=0 on each",
    "secret_references": "OpenClaw single-value file SecretRefs preserved as references; no credential conversion",
    "staging_failure": "stale canonical client identities rejected before writer cutover, catalog writes, owner replacement or admission; failed preparation retained",
    "preparation_fix": "profile, manifest and owned contract target identities rederived; shared semantic check now runs before staging mutations",
    "corrected_native_stage": "three installed native loaders accepted corrected profiles and static custody; protected stage receipt retained",
    "model_owner": "accepted model, owner image, activation and catalog preserved",
    "acceptance": "fleet acceptance remains pending; staging success does not replace new/existing-session or scheduled checks"
  }
}